Lack of tech standards complicates audit

Despite advantages, technological advancements could complicate the already complex shared audit process, according to a panel of accountants during an Accountancy Age Live Discussion on October 2. “I think potentially audit technology could be a barrier to some of the reforms, particularly in shared audits,” said Richard Spofforth, audit and assurance partner, Kreston Reeves. “What …

by | October 5, 2020 | bobsguide

Despite advantages, technological advancements could complicate the already complex shared audit process, according to a panel of accountants during an Accountancy Age Live Discussion on October 2.

“I think potentially audit technology could be a barrier to some of the reforms, particularly in shared audits,” said Richard Spofforth, audit and assurance partner, Kreston Reeves.

“What we’ll find is if you’ve got a shared audit with PwC, from a regulatory point of view they’ll probably want you to have the same audit methodologies, as will the insurers no doubt.”

Jon Wedge, audit and financial services partner, BKL, agreed, adding that technological improvements could further complicate the field.

“One of the reasons why there aren’t so many joint audits is because they’re absolutely impossible to agree. Where does one firm’s liability start, another one’s start and where do both end? They’re logistically a nightmare to organise, so the tech is not going to make that any easier. It’s probably going to add another level of difficulty to what is already a really difficult negotiation process,” he said on the panel.

The lack of standards in audit also adds room for complication. According to Wedge, a lack of guidance or auditing standards clouds the effectiveness of audit advancements, particularly those surrounding artificial intelligence (AI).

“Tech is not the silver bullet that is going to improve [audit quality]. We’ve got to be better at questioning the answers that we receive,” said Wedge.

“Personally I’d like to see the corporate governance code tightened up a bit, maybe but it more into statute law rather than it being a code of conduct, or guidelines about the way you should act. There are different levers that can be pulled here, not one of these is the sole solution – it’s a combination.”

Other panellists emphasised the importance of professional scepticism in audit when utilising AI. Kyle Gibbons, managing director, Europe, Confirmation said tech should be a complementary role in the profession.

“In terms of technology and how that applies to improving audit quality, I would say it’s a supportive role in terms of allowing that professional scepticism the air and the space to be exercised. If you’re still relying on paper-based processes, highly manual labour intensive processes – you’re not really going to have much time to exercise professional scepticism and judgement, question the client in the way you really do need to in order to provide that robust audit report that’s been looked for,” he said on the panel.

Arbinder Chatwal, audit partner at BDO said the practice of professional scepticism must evolve along with the technology.

“What’s going to be absolutely key … is the importance of having professional scepticism. If a lot of these basic tests, that journey that you have in the first few years is automated, how is that professional scepticism going to develop? That’s one area that’s very important – you’ve got to evolve that part of it,” he said.

Watch the full discussion here.
 

Categories:

Resources

Automating ATM Reconciliations

White Paper | ATM technology Automating ATM Reconciliations

AutoRek

Automating ATM Reconciliations

This paper discusses how AutoRek’s solution ensures you remain operationally resilient to the ongoing challenges while reducing costs and adapting… Continue Reading

View resource
Beyond Enterprise Data Management: Challenges of Alternatives Data Management

White Paper | Alternative investments Beyond Enterprise Data Management: Challenges of Alternatives Data Management

Meradia

Beyond Enterprise Data Management: Challenges of Alternatives Data Management

Meradia’s Managing Director Mick Cartwright, CIPM, and Principal Christine Madel, CFA, explore the challenges of alternatives data management (ADM) and… Continue Reading

View resource

New GFT podcast on AI

In the latest episode of our new podcast series on AI entitled ‘Artificial Intelligence, Intelligently Applied’, our host Simon Thompson… Continue Reading

View resource
Quartz™ Magazine - The New Age

Case Study | Consultants Quartz™ Magazine - The New Age

TCS Financial Solutions

Quartz™ Magazine - The New Age

This edition of the Quartz magazine features launch of Quartz Crypto Services, insights from our first Quartz Live event on… Continue Reading

View resource